gpolit.com
gpolit.com November 19, 2017


Options for Supreme Court on Trump travel ban

26 June 2017, 01:58 | Latoya Patrick

The parties in Murr v. Wisconsin offered the court three very different approaches to the denominator analysis.

"In my view, it would be desirable for us to take a fresh look at our regulatory takings jurisprudence, to see whether it can be grounded in the original public meaning of the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment or the Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment", he said. The lots were later transferred to his children in the 1990s.

The siblings had argued that the lot lines always define the relevant parcel.

"As the court's most important Justice-at the center of the institution's ideological balance-Justice Kennedy's ability to bridge the divide between left and right on critical issues such as the right to access abortion can not be overstated", Elizabeth Wydra, president of the Constitutional Accountability Center, told CNN.

But the end-of-term business may also produce a major decision on the right of churches and their affiliated organizations to gain equal access to government benefits that are meant to be neutral about religion, along with a highly significant ruling defining the government's power to detain in prison-like conditions immigrants who are facing deportation.

It has sometimes seemed, as the government appeals have developed, that the question of permitting or blocking the immediate enforcement of the presidential order might be the whole story. The court rejected the "formalistic" rules proposed by both the Murrs and Wisconsin. The property was appraised at $400,000 before the Murrs tried to sell it.

After a failed appeals process, the Murrs sued Wisconsin and St. Croix County, claiming the ordinance in question caused an uncompensated taking of their property because the vacant lot can't be sold or developed as a separate lot.

The court emphasized that any denominator test must ascertain, through an "objective" analysis, "whether reasonable expectations about property ownership would lead a landowner to anticipate that his holdings would be treated as one parcel, or, instead, as separate tracts". These include the treatment of the land under state and local law; the physical characteristics of the land; and the prospective value of the regulated land. With regard to the third factor, the analysis should give "special attention to the effect of burdened land on the value of other holdings". First, Wisconsin property law - specifically, the merger provision - treats the two parcels as one. The regulations barred building on any lot smaller than one acre of land. Third, the lots are more valuable when combined. If the court does not regard the immigration cases as matters of high urgency, it has the option - although probably no one expects it - to simply do nothing at this time.

The court's selection of a standard over a rule may sound like a property law technicality.

Through their attorneys at the Pacific Legal Foundation, the Murrs had argued that the two properties - the vacant lot and the lot with the cabin - have remained distinct legal entities since the family purchased them separately in the 1960s. But where does the emphasis belong - and who gets to decide?

The reason, he explained, is that when the government regulates land owned by private individuals, "it nearly never says that you can't do anything with all the property you own". These controversial issues likely explain why the justices labored over the case until the penultimate day of opinion announcements.

Chief Justice John. G. Roberts Jr. dissented in an opinion joined by Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Anthony Alito Jr.

The Constitution bars the taking of private property by the government without just compensation. The ruling "compromises the Takings Clause as a barrier between individuals and the press of the public interest". "For decades, he has been the court's most eloquent voice on the need to be color blind - why he changed his mind is something historians will debate for decades". The more certain result of Murr is that the takings analysis is now more complex. As I noted at the time Grassley made his remarks, Kennedy had hired a full slate of law clerks for the upcoming October 2017 Term as had all of the other Justices on the Court.



Other News

Trending Now

E3 2017: Microsoft isn't making a profit on the Xbox One X
The price tag of $499 is actually right on the money for many analysts, as the price is what many predicted for the Xbox One X. The original Xbox One and Ps4 struggles to hit 60fps while Xbox One promises to get at least 60fps/4K with all games.

Uber considering the future of CEO Travis Kalanick
But sources inside Uber said that the company is in discussions with Michael of a "legal nature" related to an expected exit. Uber hired former USA attorney general Eric Holder , and his law firm, Covington & Burling, to lead the investigation .

This North Carolina Law Is Straight Out of "The Handmaid's Tale"
But when he began to grab her hair so hard that she could feel it ripping out, she told him he was hurting her and he had to stop. It was important because in North Carolina, a person can not withdraw consent for sex once intercourse is taking place.

Hospital: Scalise upgraded to fair condition
After the shooting, investigators searched Hodgkinson's home in IL and a storage facility in Alexandria he began renting in April. The FBI says Hodgkinson also rented a storage facility in the city, where he kept computers and over 200 rounds of ammunition.

Not 'that far off' from passing health overhaul
President Donald Trump is bemoaning what he calls "the level of hostility" that he says has stymied bipartisanship in Washington . Medicaid is the means to independence for millions of children, seniors and adults with disabilities and their families.

The official Brexit negotiations have begun
Despite the government's posturing, the European Union was clear today it has not made a single concession to David Davis. She made it clear that Britain wants reciprocal measures for the 1.5 million British citizens living in the EU.

Anthem, Inc. (ANTM) is expected to report earnings of $3.2
Anthem comprises about 2.2% of Nordea Investment Management AB's portfolio, making the stock its 8th largest position. The company had revenue of $22.32 billion for the quarter, compared to analysts' expectations of $21.23 billion.

Italy's Valentino Rossi wins Dutch motorcycle Grand Prix
It keeps the Spaniard right in the hunt at the top of the standings when the riders head to Germany next weekend. Italian Ducati Team rider Andrea Dovizioso , victor of the last two MotoGP races, finished ninth in Q2.

New Calgary blood clinic to open in time of 'critical need'
To take your blood, the nurses will simply inject a small needle in your arm and nothing else is required to be done. There are 57 countries collecting 100% of their blood supply from voluntary, unpaid blood donors .

Lopez sets up Cilic final at Queen's
With a 5-2 lead Lopez broke again to secure his place against Cilic - who he has only beaten twice in seven previous meetings. Former champion Marin Cilic is back in the Queen's Club final seeking a second title at the Wimbledon tune-up in London.